Review: Into the Dim (Into The Dim #1) by Janet B. Taylor


Hardcover, Advanced Reader Copy, 436 pages
Expected publication: March 1st 2016 by HMH Books for Young Readers
Source: ARC from Raincoast Books

Into the Dim by Janet B. Taylor features time-traveling, a missing mother (as mothers are wont to be in YA novels), secret societies, a lovable rogue, and a badass queen.

Hope Walton’s mother’s body is never found but Hope’s father tells her there is no way she could have escaped the explosion that destroyed a building the day she was supposed to be teaching there. Hope has no choice but to accept her mother’s death as fact rather than speculation. Her grief is not helped by her father moving on and finding a replacement or her step-grandma’s increasing hostility towards her. So when Hope’s unknown aunt (mother’s sister) asks that Hope come and spend some time with her in Scotland, Hope decides to accept because anything is better than enduring her father’s new happiness and her grandma’s evilness.

So off she goes to Scotland even though she has a crazy phobia of flying. In Scotland, she finds more than she had bargained for. First is the place itself. A house (I don’t think it is a castle but I, for some reason, remember it as such) full of people she doesn’t know but who know her mother extremely well–better, Hope suspects, than she does. She finds a pair of siblings: the sister she gets along with, the brother is an ass and his hostility got old very quickly. (Hint: one side of a love triangle, perhaps.) She has a fated encounter with a lovable rogue who is very pretty to look at, is exceedingly witty and full of banter. Hope has a lot of feels for him but more on that later.

She also finds out that her mother is part of a secret society of time-traveling thieves who have very recently turned into new leafs and no longer thieve. And um, more importantly, she finds out that her mother is not dead at all–wait, actually, she is dead in this time but very much alive in another. She is stuck in the 12th century due to the evil (what else could they be?) machinations of the leader of their rival time-traveling secret society.

And it is up to Hope to rescue her mother from the plague-ridden world that is the 12th century.

Okay, so that’s the story more or less.

Things I Liked:

  1. The lovable rogue, Bran, reminded me a lot of Marissa Meyer’s Captain Thorne for whom I have the eternal soft spot. I liked him.
  2. I don’t know much (at all) of what the real Eleanor of Aquitaine was like (I know zero European history) but I do like how character in the book. She’s a strong queen who has realized her boundaries, her limitations but is able to use those very limitations in her favour. She takes her power and shapes it to work for and I appreciated her.
  3. I liked the Scottish setting. Taylor does a good job of drawing the mansion/castle (I just watched Crimson Peak so I keep on picturing that) and placing her characters in the landscape.
  4. I appreciated the quick pacing of the narrative: the tension and suspense work in tandem with the flows of the story.
  5. The time-traveling details are interesting but once again, I have read very few time-traveling novels and don’t know if people widely-read in the genre would have the same opinion as me. All I can say is that it works for me.

Things I Didn’t Like

  1. So the first time Hope meets Bran he asks her if he knows her, if they have, you know, hooked up before. Her reply?

    “I’m not one of those slutty St. Sebastian girls.”

    Yeah, the slut-shaming I am not on board with. Not to mention that Hope does not know a single thing about these girls she is judging. And if they are sluts, what does that make Bran?

  2. The lack of diversity in the novel. Unless I am mistaken, apart from one POC character, the rest of the characters are white.
  3. Collum. The brother in the sibling pair who are members of the secret time-traveling society. I spoke about his hostility earlier but he is extremely unlikable. I don’t know if he can be redeemed but I honestly don’t even care.

So yeah, this book is a mixed bag of apples and it mostly depends on the expectations with which you go into it. The parts I liked, I liked a lot and the parts I didn’t like, I didn’t like a lot. So I guess read at your own discretion.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s